From byrdie

If you’re reading this story (which you clearly are), then it’s likely that you maybe, possibly, have a Sephora spending problem. (We mean that in a good way; where are my VIB Rouge members?) That said, how each of us chooses to exercise our Sephora dependence is a bit more of a mystery—until now.

If you’ve ever caught yourself stealing glances into other people’s shopping carts in line at Sephora (and honestly, who doesn’t do that?), the following information will be of interest. We took a good look at Sephora’s best-selling lipsticks on its website to get some insight into how makeup superfans are spending their cash. Many of the products on the list are surprisingly luxe—as it turns out, Sephora shoppers have high budgets when it comes to lip products. Curious to see which ones topped the list?

Keep reading to check out three of the best-selling lipsticks at Sephora. (The results might surprise you.)

Honorable Mention

It’s no surprise that the billion-dollar brand has a loyal fanbase and a best-selling lipstick. Legendary makeup artist Pat McGrath created the creamy pigments so everyone can get the luxe model treatment. The color lasts all day long and sits comfortably on the lips in comparison to many matte formulas.

2nd Runner-Up

This matte lip stain is perfect for anyone who loves a just-kissed look. The long-wearing, smudge-proof, highly-saturated color has a whopping 130K loves on the Sephora website. Many of the shades are already sold out at Sephora, so check it out ASAP.

1st Place

Lip toppers are having quite the moment. Whether you love adding a glossy finish to your go-to lipstick or prefer wearing gloss on your bare pout, this one’s for you. With a comfortable, high-shine formula, this product’s best-selling status further proves that glossy lips are having an unmistakable moment.

Next up, 14 Bestselling Sephora Picks You Need to Know About

This story was originally published at an earlier date and has since been updated